The Stronghold received cause to celebrate this weekend for the US Independence Day: two terrific reviews for Issue #2!
First off, +Tim Shorts over at Gothridge Manor gave a blow-by-blow, article-by-article review. You can read it here. The summary: "The Stronghold is a strong entry into the OSR zine community. Which
continues to grow. I hope you all take a look at Boric's cool zine and
grab a copy or do what I did, ask for the Boric Special and get two!" As Tim says in his review, we've been friends for several years, but I don't consider that to be a shoo-in good review. Tim's honest in his praise and in his criticism. (And even better, Issue #9 of his own "Manor" 'zine is in the works!)
Then the Frugal GM gave a good, overall review, which you can read here. One point I should mention: he states that he is not a "huge fan of the way things are statted out." I hope he doesn't mind me clarifying this. Through an e-mail exchange, I learned that it was that he just didn't care for 3.5 itself--the statblock style in general--rather than something I was doing wrong. I appreciate his candor; I understand that the 3.x system is not everybody's cup of tea. That's part of why I try to include at least a balance of non-3.x and 3.x material.
I tried quite hard for Issue #2 to keep the statblocks, etc. to a minimum and to aim towards a more system-neutral approach. You'll have to pick up a copy and tell me whether you think I succeeded in my goal.
To grab a copy of Issue #2 so that you can judge for yourself, head over to Blue Moon Ink Press and follow the "Buy Now" links. While you're there, you can also still pick up a copy of Issue #1 to keep your collection complete.
1 comment:
I'm totally okay with stat blocks. For games like GURPS, Pathfinder, D&D 3x, 4e and 5e, they can be quite handy. It's easier to convert, say, a Pathfinder statblock to 1e AD&D on the fly than the other way around.
Still, I understand where you are coming from. With Loviatar I struggled with that issue until I realized that I was writing a fanzine and then I felt free to stuff those bad boys full of whatever I wanted.
I am making my way through number two and I have to commend you on your writing style. You really have a gift for writing, my friend.
Post a Comment